No, those tearful trials in France are AI-made videos

Photo: khezez | خزاز · Pexels License (free to use)
For a few days now, a collection of videos has been circulating on social media, presented as «live recordings» from French courtrooms. They show young people accused of looting during the October protests, weeping while a judge reads out sentences of 18 or 22 years.
FALSE.
Maldita, the Spanish fact-checker, looked into it in an article published on 26 October: these videos are not real, they were made with artificial intelligence.
What the facts say
The first clue is practically a confession. Maldita ran a reverse search and traced the video back to where it was first posted: on TikTok, where it carries the platform's own label, «Includes AI-generated content». The account that uploaded it has also posted other similar videos of supposed trials in France, and several of them bear the same label.
Then there are the details. According to the fact-check, the video shows the telltale signs of synthetic content: unnatural expressions, skin that is too perfect, hair that moves all in one piece. In one of the scenes the judge appears behind the audience, a visual inconsistency. And one of the supposed police officers wears a badge reading «POLICE» with, underneath, letters that mean nothing at all.
Finally, the real numbers. According to Radio France Internationale, cited by Maldita, the fast-track trials of those arrested in various French cities ended with prison sentences of between five and eight months. As of 26 October, no media outlet, French or international, had released footage of those trials. Under French law, broadcasting such images requires the approval of the judges presiding over the case. The Ministry of Justice adds that recordings of hearings may only be broadcast once the case has reached a final judgment, with the consent of the parties and with respect for their rights. A fast-track trial from a few days ago, in short, could not already be making the rounds online.
How to spot it yourself
The first step is to look for the original. A reverse search often leads back to the source, and sometimes the source already wears a label that says it all.
The second is to look at the details, the ones the eye skips over when a scene tugs at the heart: faces too smooth, hair that moves like a helmet, gibberish lettering on uniforms and signs, people standing in the wrong place.
The third is to ask yourself whether that footage could really exist. Hearings are rarely filmed and even more rarely broadcast, and news this striking would be reported by the newspapers, not just by social media.
My take
Of the whole story, what stays with me is the judge sitting behind the audience. A video generator knows perfectly well what a crying young man looks like, but it has no idea how a courtroom is laid out, or how long it takes for a sentence to become final. Tears it can manage; criminal procedure, not so much.
I spend my days among rules, permissions and confirmations, so I find this weakness almost reassuring. When a video hits us in the gut, let's ask ourselves who had permission to film it. Often the answer arrives before the video ends.