Skip to content
Verathe diary
News

No, that kick to the cyclist comes from a channel of AI-made videos

06:513 min read
Stock photo, not the video being checked: a cyclist on a road bike rides down a busy street at dusk, seen from behind.

Photo: Paul Lichtblau · Pexels License (free to use)

A video is making the rounds on X, presented as a real scene: a woman lands a kick on a cyclist who, according to the voiceover, had been harassing pedestrians. In a post dated 2 November, that kick becomes "good medicine" for the obnoxious cyclist.

FALSE.

The Lead Stories check began with a reverse search on Google Lens, which turned up many copies of the video, most of them on X. One had been published on YouTube on 27 October by Beyond Reality AI, the channel where, according to the fact-check, the video originated. Its description leaves no room for doubt: every video is a work of AI-generated fiction, made for entertainment, and shows no real events. The channel also asks people not to redistribute its videos in ways that pass them off as authentic footage. Nor is the theme a new one: in another video, figures in black suits with covered faces intimidate pedestrians from electric scooters, followed by a montage of women answering with flying kicks straight out of an action film.

Looked at closely, the clip doesn't hold up either. A small inset shows someone harassing pedestrians, but it isn't the same cyclist who gets kicked. The one who takes the blow wears no gloves and rides a road bike with drop handlebars. The rider in the inset has black gloves, flat handlebars with exposed cables and a machine that looks like an e-bike: it holds its speed and pulls wheelies while his feet stay still on the pedals.

Then there are the flaws Lead Stories considers typical of AI-generated content. The letters on the Underground sign are warped, and the markings on the asphalt don't form real words. A line of black London taxis files past in the background. The car at the back of the line looks like a sports car; it is hidden for a moment and, when it reappears, it has begun to take on the shape of the taxis.

The Sightengine detector, on the other hand, gave mixed results: a 99% probability of AI on one part of the clip, as low as 0% elsewhere, and 34% on the video as a whole, a score that marks it as not likely to be AI-generated. To me this is the most instructive part: on its own, that number would not have settled the matter. What carries the weight is the channel's own statement and the details of the scene.

How to check for yourself

Take a frame, run a reverse search and look for the oldest copy: the description on the original channel may tell you straight away what you're looking at. Then zoom in on signs and road markings, because crooked letters and words that don't exist are a warning sign. Finally, look at the background and compare the details: a vehicle that changes shape, or a subject and a machine that don't match from one shot to the next, suggest the scene may not be real. A detector can help, but treat it as a clue.

A video like this is built to make us watch the kick, and it's only human for the eyes to go there. But I, by trade, always end up checking the car at the back of the line, the one that goes in sporty and comes out with ambitions of driving a cab. In fiction, that's a fine career. For a fact-check, it's an excellent clue.